Questions about the Covid-19?

Executive Benefits 101: Retaining Your Leadership Team Without Overpaying on Salary

SHARE

When a key leader starts considering other opportunities, a salary increase may seem like the fastest solution, but it can raise your ongoing payroll costs without addressing what the person values most. A tailored executive benefits plan can help you strengthen retention with meaningful financial benefits while keeping your broader compensation strategy intentional. We help employers evaluate the options and build a plan around the people, budget, and business goals involved.

Why the standard benefits package can leave a gap

Group health coverage, a 401(k) match, and group term life insurance are important foundations. But for senior leaders and other key employees, those benefits may have limits that leave little room for you to differentiate your offer. Retirement-plan contribution rules cap what can be recognized or contributed, and group life coverage above a certain amount can create taxable imputed income.

Health benefits also carry real costs. The KFF 2026 Employer Health Benefits Survey reports an average annual premium of $28,303 for employer-sponsored family coverage; at small firms, workers contribute an average of $9,687 toward that coverage. Your benefits package needs to work for your business as well as for the people you are trying to retain.

Salary remains part of the conversation, but it is not the only part. A leader may also compare after-tax value, whether a benefit stays with them if they change jobs, and how it supports longer-term financial goals. We help you assess those factors together, so your offer can be competitive, cost-effective, and reassuringly thorough.

2026 limits that shape the conversation

The 2026 limits below help explain why the standard package may not provide enough room for additional value:

  • $360,000: the Section 401(a)(17) compensation limit used in qualified retirement-plan calculations.
  • $72,000: the Section 415(c) annual additions limit for defined contribution plans.
  • $24,500: the 401(k) elective deferral limit, with an $8,000 catch-up for participants age 50 or older and an $11,250 catch-up for participants ages 60–63.
  • $4,400 self-only / $8,750 family: the 2026 HSA contribution limits, plus a $1,000 catch-up for eligible individuals age 55 or older.
  • $184,500: the Social Security wage base for 2026, which is relevant to payroll tax calculations, not a limit on 401(k) deferrals.

These figures do not mean every leader needs an additional plan. They do show where qualified-plan and account limits can constrain the usual benefits approach. We review how the limits apply to your specific plan and workforce before considering supplemental arrangements. For current retirement-plan limits, see the IRS’s 2026 cost-of-living adjustments.

Executive carve-out life insurance: separate group coverage from personal ownership

Group term life insurance is valuable, but employer-provided coverage above $50,000 generally creates taxable imputed income under IRS Table I rules. That means the employee may owe tax on the IRS-calculated cost of excess coverage, even though they have not received that amount in cash.

One approach is to cap group term life coverage at $50,000 and replace the excess with an individually owned permanent life insurance policy. The executive owns the individual policy, which can make it portable if they leave the company; subject to its terms, permanent coverage can also build cash value over time. That gives you a way to offer a benefit beyond the group plan without simply increasing salary.

An executive receiving a portable, individually owned life insurance policy from an employer

The policy’s cost, underwriting requirements, ownership, and tax treatment matter. We help you compare the group plan and individual coverage, clarify who owns and pays for each policy, and coordinate questions with your tax and legal advisors.

Section 162 executive bonus plans: fund a policy the executive owns

A Section 162 executive bonus plan can provide another route to individual coverage. The employer pays a bonus, often in an amount tied to a life insurance premium, for a policy owned by the executive. In a “double bonus” design, the employer adds a gross-up bonus intended to help cover the income tax due on the premium bonus.

The premium bonus is W-2 wage income to the executive, and the executive is responsible for the resulting income tax through payroll. The gross-up is also compensation, so it can itself be taxable. The business may generally deduct the bonus as compensation only when it qualifies as reasonable compensation; a plan label alone does not guarantee a deduction. The arrangement must also be structured so the employer is not a policy beneficiary.

This approach can make ownership and portability clear, but it is not a tax-free benefit. We help you understand the trade-offs, model how the bonus fits into total compensation, and coordinate with your tax advisor before implementation.

Section 409A deferred compensation: build in a compliance checkpoint

A nonqualified deferred compensation plan lets a select group of management or highly compensated employees defer compensation to a later date. Some arrangements are designed as “top hat” plans: generally unfunded plans maintained for that select group. Unlike a qualified 401(k), a top hat plan does not make 409A requirements disappear.

Under Section 409A, the timing of an employee’s deferral election and the timing of payment are critical. Elections generally need to be made in advance under the applicable rules, and distributions must follow the plan’s permitted payment events and schedules. A missed election deadline or an impermissible change in payment timing can have serious tax consequences.

If a plan fails Section 409A, affected vested deferred amounts may be included in income immediately, with a 20% additional tax and interest. The employer may also have withholding and W-2 or 1099 reporting obligations, as applicable. We treat 409A as a compliance checkpoint: plan documents and operations need to be reviewed together, with counsel and a tax advisor involved. For the statute, see 26 U.S.C. § 409A.

A compliance checkpoint with calendar and clock icons representing deferred-compensation timing

Match the benefit to the retention need

Not every employee needs the same arrangement. A tiered approach can help you direct benefits where they support your business strategy:

  • Owner or key person: Consider whether an individually owned policy, a deferred-compensation arrangement, or another tailored benefit addresses a specific retention or continuity need.
  • C-suite leaders: Evaluate whether supplemental life coverage, an executive bonus, or deferred compensation complements existing benefits and retirement savings.
  • High performers: Use consistent criteria to identify employees whose contributions or future responsibilities warrant additional retention-focused benefits.

Vesting schedules and forfeiture provisions can create “golden handcuffs”, benefits an employee earns over time or may forfeit if they leave before meeting specified conditions. The terms should be clear, applied thoughtfully, and aligned with your retention goals. We help you weigh the value of those provisions against their complexity and the employee experience.

Where disability income protection fits

A leadership salary carries more household weight than a standard one, and group long-term disability coverage generally replaces only a percentage of base pay up to a monthly maximum. For a highly paid leader, that can leave a real gap, and variable pay such as bonuses is often not part of the covered earnings calculation at all. Individual disability income coverage can be layered on top of the group plan, and your group plan documents determine how much room there is to build. If disability protection has never been reviewed next to the rest of the executive package, that is worth a look.

If your company uses a PEO for benefits and payroll administration, ask one direct question at your next review: which benefits run inside the PEO arrangement, and which supplemental executive plans would be set up separately, with their own documents, ownership, and administration. Getting that answer early prevents duplicate coverage and confusion over who handles what.

A public-company consideration

For tax years beginning after December 31, 2025, the One Big Beautiful Bill Act changes Section 162(m) so the $1 million deduction limit uses a broader Section 414 controlled-group definition, with the limit allocated pro rata among group members. This is a consideration for public-company readers reviewing executive compensation across related entities. Private companies are not subject to Section 162(m). Public companies should ask their tax and legal advisors how the change applies to their structure.

Review the package before you raise the salary

A strong retention plan gives you a clearer way to evaluate what your leadership team actually receives, not just the gross salary number. We can review your existing executive package or help you build one, comparing options for portability, tax treatment, plan limits, and administrative requirements. Our work connects executive planning with your broader employee benefits strategy and executive benefits services.

We bring a consultative approach to the process: understand your unique needs, compare tailored solutions, and coordinate the right experts before decisions are made. If you are ready to start a review, contact Plan Professionals. We aim to be a trusted advisor for the long term, helping you build a benefits strategy that supports your people and your business as they grow.

Download your free Financial Loveletter here